Sugar Pie Pumpkin Seeds

Organic, Heirloom

This packet sows up to 9 mounds
5 out of 5 stars
(3 reviews)
Availability: In Stock
Since the 1800s, 'Sugar Pie' has been the standard for making terrific pies, soups, muffins, and casseroles. Small, 6"-7" fruits are also good for carving decor-size jack o'lanterns. Stores for months. Also called 'New England' pumpkin.
$4.29 3 grams (~19 seeds)

Botanical Name: Cucurbita pepo

Days to Maturity: 90–115 days

Family: Cucurbitaceae

Native: Southern United States and Mexico

Hardiness: Frost-sensitive annual

Plant Dimensions: 8'–15' vines

Variety Information: Small, round pumpkin, 6"–7" diameter, flattened at ends. Developed for cooking, 'Sugar Pie' has thick, sweet, fine-grained, orange-yellow flesh.

When to Sow Outside: RECOMMENDED. 2 to 4 weeks after your average last frost date, and when soil temperature is 70°–90°F.

When to Start Inside: Not recommended except in very short growing seasons, 2 to 4 weeks before your average last frost date. Sow in biodegradable pots that can be planted directly in the ground. Transplant after your average last frost date, when weather is warm and settled.

Days to Emerge: 7–14 days

Seed Depth: 1"

Seed Spacing: 2–3 seeds per mound

Row Spacing: 8'–12' apart

Thinning: When several leaves, thin to 1 –2 per mound

Harvesting: Harvest pumpkins before the first fall frost, and when foliage has begun to dry out. Cut stem with a knife, leaving 3"–4" of stem on the pumpkin. Do not hold the pumpkin by the stem; if stem attachment gets broken, or any part of the pumpkin bruises, the pumpkin may rot. Brush off any dirt or leaves. Ideally, cure at 80°-85°F and 80–85% humidity or a warm, sunny spot with good air circulation for 1 to 2 weeks before eating or storage. Do not allow harvested fruit to get wet.

Write a Review

Sugar Pie Pumpkin Seeds Reviews

3 reviews

Very prolific!

5 out of 5 stars Oct 13, 2020
I grew honeynut, spaghetti, lakota, jarrahdale, and sugar pie squash this year. Each honeynut produced 4-5 small squash per plant before the plant died off early on in the season. I planted 4-5 of the lakota and only got one fruit total. I planted 3-4 jarrahdale, and got one large pumpkin and one small one. I planted 3-4 spaghetti squash plant, and each plant did produce 1-2 squash before dying. Finally the sugar pie plants each produced several pumpkins and continued on through the season. It was a top performer!
Anna from PA
Owner Response: Hi Anne, Thanks for taking the time to leave a review. We are always happy to help troubleshoot issues like your plants dying, which isn't normal and could be insects or disease. Don't hesitate to contact us. Happy gardening!

So many happy pumpkins

5 out of 5 stars Nov 9, 2021
First time growing pumpkins and these did amazing! Planted one mound with 3 seeds and they took over a bit but got 9 pumpkins and the squirrels got 3. They have helped me make the best pumpkin bars for weeks now and the dog gives two paws up as she gets any extra that doesn't make it into a recipe. Definitely will plant again.
Geilesha from IA

Sugar in abundance

5 out of 5 stars Nov 11, 2021
We planted 6 plants. That's all. We got 42 pumpkins!!! AMAZING. These make such great pies and cakes! So good.
Lynn from CO
Owner Response: WOW! Thanks for sharing your experience.

You May Also Like

This website uses cookies to ensure you receive the best experience. Learn More